Episode Title: You're a Rat!
Air Date: 11-30-2006
Johnathan admits to Candice Woodcock that he had to flip or he was going home. He thinks he made the right choice and the old Aitutaki tribe is releaved but realizes it will change the whole game. Pavarti tells Johnathan Penner that she is very upset at the way he voted. Johnathan Penner tells the tribe that Yul Kwon has the idol, and they don't believe him.
Parvati had never cleaned a fish and is learning the whole process. Johnathan Penner is annoyed by Parvati Shallow at this point. Johnathan Penner is doing a lot talking trying to justify his position. The Game is an auction Johnathan Penner bids $100 for hot dog. The next item is a bubble with Chocolate cake Parvati Shallow wins for $360. The next item is a mystery gift Becky Lee buys it for $640. She gets to pick some to send someone to Exile Island and take their money. She sends Candice Woodcock for the fourth time. Yul Kwon confesses he has the Idol. The next item is an ice cream maker; Ozzy Lusth buys it for $400. Johnathan Penner buys a pizza with all of his remaining money.
Johnathan did well but he felt bad eating and not sharing. Parvati Shallow caught that the old Aitutaki tribe was mad at Johnathan Penner. Parvati Shallow tries to convince the Aitutaki tribe that Johnathan Penner should be the next to go. Johnathan Penner realizes he is in a vulnerable spot. Candice Woodcock is having an extremely hard time mentally coping with the isolation.
Tree mail lets them know they have to remember what went on in the past. Adam Gentry is gunning to send Johnathan Penner home. The challenge will be a quiz on what happened in prior challenges. Getting the answer right starts an obstacle course to move to the next round. Parvati Shallow gets it right as do Adam Gentry and Johnathan Penner. The next round is another quiz followed by another obstacle course. Adam Gentry is the first in the maze followed by Parvati Shallow and Adam Gentry wins easily.
Candice is worried she may be on the chopping block. Pavarti and Adam Gentry are trying to convince Yul Kwon to vote Johnathan Penner off. Yul Kwon is open that he can't change the game getting rid of him. Adam Gentry and Johnathan Penner are very tense. Meanwhile Candice Woodcock and Adam Gentry are getting closer. The old Aitutaki tribe is having lunch and not sharing with the remaining Rarotonga. Candice Woodcock confronts Johnathan Penner, and gets into a public argument tries to drag Yul Kwon and the rest of the tribe into the confrontation. The fight creates quite a bit of tension. Yul Kwon realizes that they can vote Johnathan Penner off and put himself in a good position with the jury.
Candice gets 5 votes and is voted off the island.