Episode Title: Secrets and Lies and an Idol Surprise
Air Date: 11-10-2005
On the way back from Tribal Council Jamie Newton is still upset that at the argument he had with Bobby Jon Drinkard and Brandon Bellinger. Jamie Newton appears to be taking it very personally. He and Bobby Jon Drinkard continue to lock horns. Bobby Jon Drinkard is worried and looking for the immunity idol as is Danni Boatwright.
For the reward challenge members have to use an ancient Mayan weapon to throw a spear at a target on the ground. The reward is food, the closest person wins the best meal, and a clue to the immunity idol. Jamie Newton places 4th but offers to take last place to atone for last nights actions.
Judd gets first place and gets a steak and lobster dinner. Cindy Hall wins chicken and vegetables. Danni Boatwright gets a plate of spaghetti and meatballs. Stephenie Lagrossa wins a hamburger. Gary Hogeboom wins pizza. Rafe Judkins wins a ham and cheese sandwich. Bobby Jon Drinkard wins a baked potato. Lydia Morales wins fish, and Jamie Newton wins small ramon nuts. Judd Sergeant gets to invite to people to sit at his table and share his food and open bar, he chooses Stephanie and Bobby Jon Drinkard. Meanwhile Gary Hogeboom looks thin and not happy about getting only a slice of Pizza. Bobby Jon Drinkard says he is trying to be respectful and not offend the other players. Judd Sergeant is having a good time and drinking too much. On the way back to camp Judd Sergeant is drunk and tripping and falling, in the middle of the night he gets sick at camp. Jud reveals the clue about the immunity idol to Stephanie it says it is up in the air. However he tells the rest of the tribe it's on the ground. Gary Hogeboom tells Jamie Newton he is going to vote with him, Jamie Newton misinterprets this as he is voting for him. Most of the tribe is getting worried about Jamie Newton that he may be getting a little unstable.
For the immunity challenge all 9 tribe members will race across a balance bean to untie two wooden planks only four will advance. Using the planks the four will race across a rope bride where only two will advance. The last leg will be a two line rope bridge. Stephanie, Jamie Newton, Gary Hogeboom and Rafe Judkins make it to the second leg. Jamie Newton and Rafe Judkins win and make it to the next round. Rafe Judkins falls in the water and Jamie Newton wins.
Back at camp discussions about who is going to be voted out are all around. Jamie Newton was going to get voted out but got immunity. Gary Hogeboom knows he is probably going to get voted out so he looks for the idol. He notices Judd Sergeant looking also but Judd Sergeant looks up. Gary Hogeboom wonders why he is looking up when he told them to look down.